So I want to talk to you about AI.
Okay.
Your face drops.
You’re like, “Oh…”
God, I’m trying to catch myself.
Because I hate a lot to do with AI. I obviously think it’s fantastic, and the way that everything’s moving is terrifying but brilliant, right? We can get so much more done.
My gripe, which I’m sure is yours, is that now every man and their dog thinks they can create copy, they can be a graphic designer, they can make websites or whatever because AI has one tool that creates it. Click a button and suddenly something’s been generated with no quality control.
I feel like copy has been hit the hardest.
I have friends who are copywriters, and they’ve been bouncing from job to job over the last few years because they just can’t get jobs. In-house copywriters are being sacked off for ChatGPT.
It’s tough, right?
And I know there are always these quotes out there saying AI won’t replace your jobs, but a person with AI skills will, and all this sort of stuff.
But I want to talk about how AI has affected copywriting, how you guys use it to your advantage, because you’re going to need to otherwise you’re going to be left behind.
And ChatGPT has gotten smarter. Don’t get me wrong. You can train it, and actually some of the stuff it spits out is semi-decent.
But at the end of the day, it doesn’t do all of that stuff you’ve already talked about. It doesn’t do the research or strategy pieces either.
So it can do the words, but it doesn’t do the first two sections, right?
Exactly.
Maybe to an extent, but it’s not very good.
Talk to me about your feelings about ChatGPT these days, copy producers, and the state of copywriting in the world of ChatGPT.
I think the best way to answer that question is to share our journey when it comes to AI.
First thing to say is that as an agency, we’ve very much embraced the AI revolution, or the Gen AI revolution, from an early stage.
Even prior to ChatGPT coming along and blowing up the internet and all the fearmongering around the death of copywriting and the end of the world, so prior to that you know GPT technology was already there for a couple of years.
There were certain tools using GPT such as Copy.ai and Jasper, formerly Jarvis, which was formerly Conversion.ai. Initially.
As an agency, we’re quite methodical. We like to plan ahead and future-proof the agency.
We had our collective finger on the pulse of large language model development for that reason. We’d already tested some of those tools and understood that they were okay, but they couldn’t create the kind of quality that we offer as an agency.
Then ChatGPT came along and blew up the internet and woke the world up to how advanced AI technology is.
OpenAI did two very smart things.
First, it was free, which is why it went completely viral.
But also I think in terms of the application the fact that it’s so far reaching and broad. I think that’s something that’s very very unique. One of the things that has really propelled open AI to like the front of this race because prior to that, there were tools that used the technology but within a very specific application.
Like for social media.
Yeah. Exactly.
For doing that specific thing here’s the input here’s a question answer that that’s the input.
Whereas ChatGPT is this much more human-like chatbot that goes back and forth, and the sky’s the limit in terms of use cases.
Anyway what it did when it launched, it really lit a fire under us as an agency to accelerate our embracement of the technology and our stance on it and our perspective on it.
I mean that well the perspective kind of things I went on podcasts like this. I was quite vocal, and still am, on LinkedIn about the strengths and limitations of AI and how to use it and not use it.
Our stance is that its collaborative the now and future of copywriting, at least for I don’t know how many years until there’s AGI when they enslaves the human race, which we won’t talk about right now, our start is that it is to get the best result it’s collaboration between AI and humans.
What we did was launch very quickly an agency-wide use case testing project.
Very structured. Very thorough.
We broke down all our services we offer, buyer interviews, brand DNA workshops, content strategy workshops, homepage copy, writing a blog posts, everything in between.
We put it all into spreadsheets different tabs and we broke them each down into several into different steps that it takes to kind of deliver that piece of work.
Then we created a scoring matrix based on how likely we thought AI could speed up or improve that particular step, and also how much we disliked that particular step.
And I think that’s a really important thing to remember is likability.
Because in the end of the day I’ve got an agency of very talented team members, and there’s no point argumenting a process to speed it up by 20% if that particular task is the reason they love being a copywriter. Right?
Because AI is an option. It’s not the option.
It’s not that you have to use it. It’s a tool.
It’s automation is very sophisticated automation.
We’ve been automating tasks since the Industrial Revolution and especially over the last thirty years.
Generative AI is just a much more sophisticated way of automating certain task which they call task encroachment so it is encroaching on a newer tasks that we perhaps thought technology couldn’t.
So we ran this big use case testing project.
The whole team involved. There was a bit of change management that we had to sort of think about, because I think and I maybe rushed it a bit too fast without really helping the team understand why we were embracing AI and naturally there was fear there. Right? There was natural fears from copywriters going well hang on what
“Are you replacing us? Are we just going to churn out AI copy?”
We had to sort of educate the team and go no this is what we believe in, we believe it’s a collaboration, we believe that what we need to be doing in this age is
embracing the technology and understanding how we can use it in a right way and how not to use it.
A year later, we basically like we really understood the strengths and limitations.
I’ll pause there and I’ll talk about what some of those are because
I think that’s really important.
I think the reality is yes, lots of marketers and non-marketers are just churning out content and copy just with AI a simple prompt and the problem with that is that and the reason why we don’t use it just to write a you know write the copy for our clients if it was good enough, we’d have pivoted as an agency at the end of the day.
I’m a businessman and that’s what we would have done I wouldn’t have just said no we must stick to the old ways.
If it could compete with human copywriters, then we’d be using it in that way.
But the reason why you can’t just prompt ChatGPT to write good enough copy at least good enough for the kind of quality that we offer is
because the way the tool works is predictive.
Now, I’m going to describe this in simple terms because I’m not like you know an AI developer. So, anyone listening might be like what’s he talking about but simplistically the way it works is that it chooses the next word based on like how likely it is that the next word would be in the sentence. So kind of like based on your prompt and also what it’s learned from which is billion of billions of data points out there.
You see this on predictive text in your phone right and you see it on your phone.
Exactly like predictive text on your phone. So it’s predictive it’s based on kind of how likely that word is going to come with some variability that variability is needed in order to make it seem more human and to give different results all the time even if it was a even if it most likely it would just give everyone exactly the same content.
So there’s variability in there but the reason why I’m saying all this is because CHATGPT has learned its copywriting skills from the internet. right. Billions of day at point out there on the internet is mostly average and at best.
At best.
And crappy copy.
Exactly.
Because of the reasons we said before marketers being lazy, etc..
One of the main sort of practices in copy is to avoid clichés. Clichés don’t work because people just go “I’ve read that before” you know.
Basically ChatGPT is prone to writing clichés copy because of the reasons. As I said it’s prone, it learned its copywriting skills from the internet, and the internet is full of average and cliches and things you shouldn’t write if you want to differentiate cut through the noise and really grab the attention of your audience.
So, it’s prone to writing cliche copy and that’s why you can see in LinkedIn. Mostly you can see when someone’s just prompted and they created it.
It’s kind of vague.
Often doesn’t really say much.
There’s no authenticity or personal anecdotes and actual true experience.
There are other things like too many emojis and like clichéd phrases. Which again we tried to avoid.
So, it’s a shortcut and lazy marketers will use it and are using it. But like I said at the beginning
lazy marketers were already not using copywriters and they were writing themselves so we were always kind of against that lazy marketer in a sense I say lazy but also marketers who just maybe you’re not lazy that’s probably let me pull that back.
Marketers who don’t understand the importance and power of like really good copy and the effect of really good copy and don’t know what they’re looking for so someone wrote this comment one of my LinkedIn post a year ago and I can’t remember who it is so I kind of stolen the quote for myself and I apologize to this person but they said “the best way to write great copy using AI is by being a great copywriter otherwise , garbage in, garbage out.”
Yes.
That’s the main point is.
It’s the same when it comes to design.
The reality is it’s a tool it’s very sophisticated, it’s definitely approaching on certain tasks but it has strengths and limitations.
You need to understand where those strengths and limitations are and if you’re using it you need to know what the output should be otherwise you’re not going to get a great copy.
That’s how I feel about Canva.
Yeah.
It’s the same thing with design because I’ve been saying this again, Canva it’s been around for years and is absolutely fantastic tool but back when it first came out pre-chatgpt and everything I hated it it was like my most loaded tool because all these clients came to me same way they probably come to you now and well I could just plug that chatgpt and it’s I don’t need to pay you for it I could just do that in canva that’s what they say, and I don’t need to pay you to do graphic design work. I’m like, you don’t have any branding foundational knowledge at all. You’re just basically taking templates and changing pictures, and it looks awful. There’s no consistency of quality, tone, anything. There’s no element of branding. But they would do this, and they could turn out loads of stuff, and they felt like graphic designers. It was really interesting.
But you know, you can create amazing stuff on Canva, and Canva is a fantastic tool. Even now at our agency, good designers have been using Canva. I’ve been using Canva myself for certain things. It’s actually quicker than using Adobe, but it would look great if I do it because I have how many years of foundational knowledge of graphic design. I can put it in there.
Like you said, to make good copy from ChatGPT, be a good copywriter. To make great designs on Canva, be a good designer in the first place. It’s not the tool. It’s actually the human getting the knowledge, the experience, the expertise, the eye.
Yeah, it’s so true.
My dad was a graphic designer and an illustrator, right? He used to draw logos by hand, literally, and then draw a large logo, scan it in, and downsize it. He was a successful graphic designer. Then home computers came along and the Photoshop suite, Macs, and he had a Mac, but he was just terrible with technology. He was slow to the uptake. He wasn’t interested and just wasn’t naturally good with technology.
So he pivoted. He just couldn’t keep up. But the reality was, you know, that was a tool. It’s not that anyone can be a graphic designer because they’ve got Photoshop. You still need the eye, the experience, and understand what you’re aiming to achieve.
And it’s the same with using ChatGPT to create copy and content that is good enough. Again, back to the point, good enough to convert, good enough to actually cut through the noise, good enough to grip people’s attention, good enough to use the psychology needed to influence them.
There’s so much that goes into it, from research, strategy, and competitor analysis to cognitive biases. ChatGPT doesn’t include all of that. It usually just gets the go-to cliché stuff.
However, as you said, a copywriter using ChatGPT or other tools in the right way, I think, is the future.
So this now, I’ll go back to my story.